YouTube keeps sharing videos of people who voted for Trump asking for forgiveness and those who didn’t vote for Trump explaining why ex-MAGA don’t deserve forgiveness. I’m not sure how I feel. I can say one things for sure, my feelings at the moment are mixed. I want to feel compassion, yet so much damage has been done. So many lives have been destroyed in some shape or form. Obviously I could write on this for days. I decided today, just to work out some of my basic thoughts on the matter.
I had to look at this from several angles:
- Severity of the transgression
- Knowledge and understanding of the transgression
- Acceptance of responsibility vs. projection
- Remove the “I” factor
- Actually change in behavior, not just stating you are sorry
There could be more, but these are the ones I find most poignant at the moment.
- I strongly disagree with MAGA when they say this is just politics. Trump elevated everything to extremism where human rights were being abused, and morality was called into question: protecting pedophiles, shooting innocent girls in Iran, shooting fisherman off Venezuela, shooting Americans in the streets, abusing immigrants, denying U.S. aid abroad, denying U.S. aid through FEMA, taking away rights, and abusing women. MAGA, you are not losing friends because of politics, you are losing friends because you support and vote for atrocities.
- I do believe we have to take into account as to wether or not the transgressor fully knew and understood what they were doing. I feel most of MAGA should have known this. Trump displayed a lot of these characteristics his first term and/or made it very clear what he was going to do his second term. Everything was laid out clearly in the Big Beautiful Bill and Project 25. Huge amounts of information were available everywhere. If you claim ignorance, then you should no longer have the right to vote, because clearly you will remain uninformed forever and ever and vote how your told, not how you think and believe.
- You have to take responsibility for your actions. Don’t make excuses. Don’t blame others. I think this is what bothers me the most in some of these videos. If you’re making excuses and blaming others, you are not on a path to change. You will repeat the same behavior in the future.
- You need to remove the “I” factor. This shouldn’t be all about you. It should be about acknowledging the harm you’ve done to others. I see very little of that. I see a lot of victim role playing.
- You can’t just say you are sorry and move on, which is what I see in a lot of these videos. I rarely hear “I’m going to try to vet my information,” “I’m going to talk to friends and family for second opinions,” “I’m going to really think about what people are telling me.” Almost none of them explain how they are going to become better people if they are forgiven.
Again, I’m just some low income dude thinking out loud on my basic thoughts. I’m not trying to write a moral thesis.
I have not made a final conclusion on how I will treat ex-MAGA asking for forgiveness, but I think a starting point with me would be to treat them like alcoholics in recovery. I’m willing to forgive you and give you another chance if you can demonstrate to me you are changing our lifestyle (in this case thinking) and that you are trying to think about others more than yourself and maybe even find ways to serve others rather than yourself.